Where do I go to see native butterflies?
Start with your own yards, especially if you have a diversity of flowers, native or not. Go back to your local Arboretum (Los Angeles Arboretum) or Botanic Gardens (Descanso Gardens) and focus on flowering shrubs and herbs for butterflies. Pause on your hikes at stands of flowers for a while and see what’s there. Once you train your eyes, you will find native butterflies and other interesting insects. The camera is the best way to bring butterflies home with you for study.
How do I tell a butterfly from a moth?
Both butterflies and moths have four wings and are in the same Order of insects, Lepidoptera, which translates “scale-winged”. The majority of moths fly by night while butterflies are out during the day. Butterflies hold their wings together vertically over the body and moths fold them roof-like over the back. The antennae on butterflies have a club at the tip while in moths they are thread-like or feathery. Also, with exceptions, moths are more muted in color, tending to grays and browns, while butterflies are often more colorful.
What is their life history?
All butterflies undergo complete metamorphosis; that is they go from egg to larva (caterpillar) to pupa to adult. This is a remarkable transformation from a worm-like stage to a four-winged adult ready to fly off to feed on nectar, avoid predators and locate a host plant for egg laying.
Cloudless Sulphur Caterpillar
Cloudless Sulphur Butterfly
Two kinds of plants are needed to sustain butterflies.
Adult butterflies find nectar on flowers using their specialized straw-like proboscis. Sometimes many flower species are visited by “generalist” butterflies while others may nectar on one or a few flowers, the “specialists”. However, for egg-laying and caterpillar food the host plant may be more specific to a single species or family of plants. Examples of host plants: Cabbage White = mustards. Western Tiger Swallowtail = cottonwood, ash, alder, willows. Mourning Cloak = willows, cottonwoods, elms. Red Admiral = nettles.
nectaring on Alkali Heliotrope
Stinging Nettle host plant
Giant Swallowtail Butterfly
Do you have an orange, lemon or lime tree in your yard? Then you should see the Giant Swallowtail cruising in circles, looking to land and lay eggs on these citrus family plants.
How long do butterflies live as adults?
For most butterflies, life is short. An adult butterfly probably has an average life-span of approximately one month; smaller ones less, larger ones a little more. In the wild, most butterflies’ lives are shorter than this because of the dangers provided by predators, disease, and large objects, such as automobiles. The smallest butterflies may live only a week or so, while a few butterflies, such as Monarchs, Mourning Cloaks and tropical heliconians, can live up to nine months. (NABA website). Many can overwinter in the egg, larval or pupal stage.
Monarch, nectaring on its host plant,
Do butterflies have a sense of smell?
Yes, they have chemoreceptors at the ends of their antennas and on the bottoms of their “feet!” They can locate a plant they’re looking for, find mates and sense rivals in the air through tiny holes in the antennas, and then taste what they land on with sensory equipment in their feet.
Who are butterfly predators?
It’s a tough life out there. Birds, spiders, insects like praying mantis and wasps, lizards, toads and frogs and small mammals, all eat butterflies or their caterpillars. Some butterflies, like Monarchs and Queens, ingest plant toxins, incorporated into their bodies, while feeding as caterpillars, and are avoided by predators.
Do butterflies migrate?
Most butterflies remain in the area where their host food plants are located. But some are long-range migrants up to thousands of miles. Our well-known migrants include Monarchs, Painted Ladies, Red Admirals, and Cloudless Sulphurs, with most of these moving northward following warming weather. For most this is a one-way trip as they lay eggs to complete their mission, and then die with the cold weather. Exceptions are the famous Monarchs who can move north through the U.S. then return south to mild wintering grounds in the southern U.S. and into Mexico. As for Painted Ladies, you’ve probably noticed the mass migration of orange and black butterflies in early Spring through our area, moving from east to west. The numbers of these Painted Ladies in some good rain years are astounding and may make the papers or television news.
How can I learn to identify them?
You can watch butterflies with close-focusing binoculars sometimes within 8 to 10 feet, but use a digital camera with some zoom capability to photograph butterflies when they land. Try to get the upperside and underside of wings, if the subject will allow. Some will only show you one or the other. Study your photos with field guide help or websites for identification. Pay attention to whether a species is in your area based on range maps. Once you know a butterfly’s name it opens the door to studying more about their range, both geographical and elevational, their habitats, and food for caterpillars. Are they common or rare? What seasons do they fly?
Wandering Skipper doesn’t ~ Mickey Long
Wandering Skipper – San Diego
“There are quite a few types of “skippers” out there, the little orangey guys who look rather moth-like. On our last day of a San Diego visit in September 2017, my wife and I found a small slough or marsh in San Diego that looked good for birds. As we started to circle the pond a little brownish skipper landed on yellow blooms of a coastal goldenbush in front of us. I aimed my camera and got one shot and came home with a photo to find a new endangered species, for me. A wandering skipper. “
Wandering Skipper – Malibu
“Fast forward to July 2020 and a visit to Malibu Lagoon along the Los Angeles County coast, with another naturalist friend, and a brown skipper landing on another coastal goldenbush. This triggered a memory of the San Diego butterfly and habitat, but it required photo-checking at home to confirm another wandering skipper. I don’t know how far the wandering skipper travels, but it can’t live without its salt grass for its caterpillar to eat and it hugs the dwindling coastal zone marshes of California. This is biogeography that ties plants and animals to habitats, specialized foods, climate zones and all. It’s fun to go looking for something exactly where you know it to be, but it’s even more fun to “wander” into something new!”
Are butterflies declining? Are there endangered butterflies?
Entomologists and the general public have been asking “where have all the butterflies gone?” Numbers are down, especially in the cities and suburbs with only a few adaptable species seen most of the time. The biggest culprit is widespread development of habitat. A diversity of wild plants supports a diversity of butterflies, and we have replaced especially the native food plants that butterfly larvae must have to survive. Adults may be able to nectar on some of our ornamental introductions, but that does little to support the full life cycle.
At least four species or subspecies of southern California butterflies are Federally-listed as Endangered. The El Segundo Blue, Palos Verdes Blue, Quino Checkerspot and Laguna Mountain Skipper each have unique ranges, habitats and host plants. Some other species may be common but occur in only one or a few places, like the Veined Blue in the high San Gabriel Mountains.
Monarch, nectaring on its host plant,
Veined Blue on host Wright’s Buckwheat
How is AFC helping?
Virtually all of these butterlies occur on our AFC preserves and we continue to help them out by restoring native plants and removing invasive non-natives. We care about native pollinators since we want healthy, balanced natural ecosystems and since one out of every three bites of food we eat depends on pollinators.
We have not conducted systematic surveys for butterflies on AFC’s Preserves but we’ve been keeping an eye out. Using the known listing for Los Angeles County we could expect up to 50 species on our AFC Preserves. By protecting the varied habitats on our sites and removing invasive nonnative plants we work to preserve and enhance butterfly populations. In our Millard Canyon Preserve, during general flora and fauna surveys, we’ve confirmed about 16 species. We’d like to know more about which species are on our sites.
What can I do to attract and help butterflies?
Plant native flowering shrubs and wildflowers that attract adults and learn which plants supply food for their caterpillars. There’s a big move on to plant milkweeds (Asclepias spp.) in urban areas for Monarchs. There are about 9 kinds of native milkweeds in Southern California, and a number of them are available in native plant nurseries. Common ones sold, either as seed or containers, are Narrow-leaved Milkweed (Asclepias fascicularis), Kotolo or Indian Milkweed (Asclepias eriocarpa), California Milkweed (Asclepias californica), and Woolly Milkweed (Asclepias vestita). Some people like the exotic, colorful Tropical Milkweed (Asclepias curassavica), readily accepted by Monarchs. However, there is controversy that because it grows into winter it may keep monarchs from migrating and there are discussions of a protozoan parasite of monarch butterflies that can travel with monarchs visiting the plants and become deposited on leaves. Probably best to stick with the natives above. Much more information is available here: https://xerces.org/sites/default/files/publications/19-004.pdf.
Don’t use pesticides in your garden. While they are sold with high hopes, butterfly houses, with narrow slits supposed to allow them into a safe, warm roost, do not work according to experts. So put your money into plantings. A few known butterfly attractors include Wild Lilacs (Ceanothus), Buckwheats (Eriogonum), Goldenrod (Solidago californica or multiradiata), Deerweed (Acmispon glaber), Yarrow (Achillea millefolium), and sunflowers (native and ornamental) like Asters, Thistles, Coreopsis, and Zinnias. Join organizations that study and protect butterflies like the North American Butterfly Association and Xerces Society. Their websites below and the publications listed provide much information on planting for butterflies.
References for Butterfly Study
Brock, Jim P. and Kenn Kaufman. 2003. Field Guide to Butterflies of North America. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publ. Co.
Brown, Brian V. (Editor). 2009. Butterfly Gardening in Southern California. Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County.
Glassberg, Jeffrey. 2001. Butterflies through Binoculars: The West. Oxford Univ. Press
Heath, Fred and Herbert Clarke. 2004. An Introduction to Southern California Butterflies. Mountain Press Publ. Co., Missoula, Montana.
Southern California Butterflies: http://socalbutterflies.com/index.htm
North American Butterfly Association: www.naba.org
Xerces Society: www.xerces.org